We live in uncertain times where the best form of investment can often be disinvestment, normal returns are now the new norm and the concept of risk-free return is as likely as a fully subscribed Greek bond auction. Financial markets that once were driven by company performance now fluctuate wildly on the slightest political gaffe and fear makes market-timing an impossibility. So, in the midst of turmoil, where can a modicum of certainty be found? Perhaps it is time to venture out!
The humble Venture Capital Trust (VCT) was conceived by Kenneth Clarke in 1995 and its purpose was to facilitate the raising of capital for UK start-up companies. The carrot of generous tax-breaks, including initial Income Tax relief and no exit taxes, encouraged the growth of the market. Today VCT companies attempt to raise in excess of £400m each tax year in total to fund new ventures.
In the early years, the allure of the tax relief and the prospect of high returns encouraged many to invest in what were highly speculative ventures, many of which eventually failed. Since the VCT boom created in 2004 by the temporary increase in tax relief, companies have sought to innovate and create products that deliver – and this is backed up by the performance figures. A recent search of the Allenbridge database shows there are still 100 active VCTs launched in or after the 2005/6 tax year. Of those, 15 have a positive total return, 51 are returning over 90% of the initial investment and rest are valued at over 70%, i.e. none show a negative return to the investor when the tax relief has been taken into account.
The performance is probably unsurprising when one considers the current levels of expertise in some companies and some of the risk management techniques currently employed – the Albion investment team have been working together in this market for 16 years and Octopus employ a “Dragon’s Den” approach to investment selection. So there may be a case for investing into a VCT just to secure the tax relief in the knowledge that, even if the manager performs badly, you should at least be able to get your money back.
There are, however, downsides which include a lack of transparency of the investments: the manager claims to have a deal-flow but cannot, for obvious reasons, disclose the actual investments; the high costs – 5 to 6% initial charges and running costs of up to 3.5% per annum; and lack of liquidity – there is no effective second-hand market and no tax relief on “used” VCTs.
The initial income tax relief (30%) and the tax-free returns are compelling reasons to invest, as is the potential return, and in an economic climate where banks are still not lending to small companies, a myriad of opportunities exists for venture capitalists. Additionally, VCTs can provide diversification in a portfolio as private equity performs very differently from equity markets and tax-free dividends are a useful planning tool.
Current thinking categorises VCTs fall into four camps: generalist, AIM, limited life and specialist. Generalist and AIM VCTs are open-ended and the manager has ultimate discretion on the style of investment. The reason for investing into these types of VCT would generally be the long-term tax free dividend stream and the diversification they add to a portfolio. My pick in this sector is the Albion VCT, which is a top-up to seven existing VCTs with a mature portfolio of 60 diverse companies and an existing dividend stream of 5% per annum.
Limited-Life VCTs aim to do what the label states – return capital within a five to six year time frame. However this gives the manager little time to invest and usually the good managers of these VCTs can return 90-95p in the pound. In recent years, Downing have demonstrated that they can create these returns in difficult markets and they are currently seeking funds; Puma also have a good track record and are worth consideration.
Specialist VCTs invest in niche markets. The flavour this tax year, until the Government poured cold water on the schemes, was the feed-in-tariffs for solar panel installations. Octopus is still raising funds for these ventures and, if the client is prepared to accept the additional political and technological risks, this VCT is worth consideration.
Investment into a VCT used to be a roller-coaster adventure and the outcome was never certain. Today the market has matured and, if one can get over the charges and the lack of transparency, VCTs can have a place in a diversified portfolio for the sophisticated investor. Their performance has held up during one of the most volatile periods of investment history and they are well-placed to benefit from any green shoots of recovery. It is time to venture out.

